Secretary of State makes unsubstantiated ‘terrorist threat’ claim

by Christian Grantham - 9:17 am - June 25th, 2009

Tennessee Regulatory AuthorityThis shocking use of TBI to intimidate proponents of fair elections in Tennessee by Secretary of State Tre Hargett deserves attention. What’s more shocking is how very little local media seems to care. Jeff Woods cares.

Newly installed Republican Secretary of State Tre Hargett sicked the TBI on a political opponent on a trumped-up charge of making a “terrorist threat.” The case is now closed, the TBI having found no justification for Hargett’s complaint. Yes, it matters who governs.

Bernie Ellis, founder of the group Gathering to Save Our Democracy, says TBI agents came to his farm yesterday to question him about whether he threatened the Secretary of State’s office in an email. Ellis said he never sent an email to that office, and the agents left after asking him a few questions.

Pith phoned Hargett’s spokesman, Blake Fontenay, for comment today. Guess what? He’d love to talk, of course, but he just can’t. The TBI won’t let him, he says, “because they’re still investigating.” Yes, it’s the old “we never comment on pending investigations” trick.

“I really am not supposed to say anything more than that at this point,” Fontenay apologized. “We’d love to respond but we were asked by the TBI specifically not to respond. There definitely is another side to this, and we wish we could talk about it, but it’s not usually advisable to get the TBI mad at you. My hands are tied at this time.”

So then we phoned the TBI, whose spokeswoman Kristin Helm said basically there is no investigation, and she doesn’t know what Fontenay is talking about.

“We had to go pay Bernie a little visit,” Helm said. “We had a public official who felt as though he was being threatened, who felt there was something floating around in cyberland that was a threat. A couple of agents went to talk to Bernie and pretty much found the threats were unsubstantiated.”

Let’s explore what the Battle of Athens was all about. In a nutshell, it was about citizens of McMinn Tennessee , returning G.I.s from World War II, taking up arms against corrupt government officials who obstructed justice and subverted the constitutional rights of voters in McMinn, TN to have their voices count in fair elections.

That doesn’t sound like the actions of terrorists to me. It sounds a lot like the kind of heroes Americans are currently rallying behind in Iran.

On 2 August 1946, some Americans, brutalized by their county government, used armed force to overturn it. These Americans wanted honest, open elections. For years they had asked for state or Federal election monitors to prevent vote fraud — forged ballots, secret ballot counts, and intimidation by armed sheriff’s deputies — by the local political boss. They got no help.

These Americans’ absolute refusal to knuckle-under had been hardened by service in World War II. Having fought to free other countries from murderous regimes, they rejected vicious abuse by their county government. These Americans had a choice. Their state’s Constitution - Article 1, Section 26 - recorded their right to keep and bear arms for the common defense. Few “gun control” laws had been enacted.

Read more from bloggers across the state:

Newscoma:

I remember when I thought my vote counted. I’ve said it before, if I can get a receipt for a quarter pounder with cheese, why can’t I get one when I vote?

Liberadio:

Or perhaps election integrity activist Bernie Ellis is guilty of misuse of a metaphor. But what he is decidedly not guilty of - contrary to the opinion of Secretary of State Tre Hargett - is making a “terrorist threat” against the government of the state of Tennessee.

Tom Humphrey:

Ellis said he had never sent any emails to the secretary of state’s office, but has occasionally invoked the Battle of Athens in his writings as “the only alternative available to the citizenry if the sanctity of the ballot box cannot be assured.”

Ellis was active in the past legislative session opposing legislation that would have postponed until 2012 the scheduled replacement of voting machines in most Tennessee counties. The postponement bill failed, leaving current law in place that calls for the new machines to be available by the 2010 elections.

Michael Silence:

Hmmmmmm. Why does “abuse of power” come to mind?

Pith in The Wind:

Here’s the moral of this little tale of jackassery: Don’t mess with aging hippies. They’re meaner than you think. Hargett sees them as a bunch of pansies. But the pansies kicked his ass on this legislation, so he was embarrassed and decided it was time for payback. Sending a couple of TBI agents to Ellis’ house would screw with his mind. Right? Unfortunately for Hargett, Ellis, who’s a really nice guy, has more than a few friends in the media. As soon as the TBI left his farm, he sat down at his computer and sent an email to these friends. When the first blog post hit the web, it must have been an oh-shit moment for the new secretary of state.

Memphis Flyer:

Thereupon the Battle of Ellis’ Farm ended without the firing of a single shot — a victory over state power, it would seem, in defense of the First Amendment which, in this case, had been exercised, in the most innocuous possible way, to refer to a long-ago circumstance involving the Second Amendment.

10 Responses to “Secretary of State makes unsubstantiated ‘terrorist threat’ claim”

  1. [...] TENNESSEE: Secretary of State makes unsubstantiated ‘terrorist threat’ claim. The “Battle of Athens” is, in fact, approvingly referenced in the state’s [...]

  2. Michael Chaney says:

    Isn’t filing a false claim a felony? Or are those only for little people?

  3. Michael Geer says:

    If voting really made a difference, I’d be first in line.

    But in 38 years of being eligible to vote, I’ve never been able to meet with any of my elected Representatives other than when they want my money. Even then I’ve not been able to get a single one to speak with me as any of us do with one another … what we really think. I mail them letters, I get back weapons grade whargarble. In short, they want nothing to do with me, and it appears after 56 years of experience …. elections are decided in some manner other than us citizens ‘casting votes’.

    I’m convinced that one of Almighty God’s chief reasons for our time on this planet is to prove to us through millenniums of excruciating experience that we cannot rule ourselves. Because there’s no recorded History to the contrary where we did a good job, unless it was Jeremiah Johnson when he was by himself.

  4. [...] week, Tennessee Secretary of State Tre Hargett abused his authority and claimed a proponent of fair elections made a “terrorist threat” by merely [...]

  5. Richard of Oregon says:

    Sounds to me like Bernie Ellis got a standard statement from the TBI agents at the end of an interview. It doesn’t seem likely that they could drop the case on the spot, in the field. If TBI dropped it after filing and reviewing the case, they probably aren’t compelled to let poor Bernie know that he was no longer muzzled. So, Bernie thinks he is still muzzled but may not be. If Pith got the correct status on the case from TBI representative Fortenay then Bernie can speak out. Sounds to me like Bernie, or better yet his attorney, should send TBI a letter asking them to clear this up, in writing, of course. No problem if Fortenay was right and he would be in a good position to move forward on this if he needs to.

  6. Bernie Ellis says:

    Richard of Oregon: you need to re-read the “Nashville Is Talking” story above and (more importantly) click on all of the embedded links in the story. TBI issued a statement immediately after their two agents visited my farm stating that there was no basis for Secretary of State Hargett’s complaint that I had made a “terrorist threat against a public official”. In fact, they did so to directly contradict Blake Fontenay’s statement that the TBI was ongoing with their investigation. (Mr. Fontenay is not a spokesman for the TBI but rather a mouth-picece for the Secretary of State who filed the false charges.) As for me being muzzled, it is obvious we’ve never met.

    So again, Richard, read the story again and visit the many embedded links that will clear up your confusion. Then hide and watch … this story is far from over.

  7. [...] Ellis, who had the TBI pay him a visit on bogus charges of terrorism over a comment he left online, is filing complaints against [...]

  8. [...] of State Tre Hargett recently sent the TBI to investigate Bernie claiming he made a “terrorist threat” against the Secretary of [...]

  9. [...] A handful of Republicans opposed to using verifiable paper ballots in Tennessee elections, including Sen. Bill Ketron (R-Murfreesboro), failed this session to get the law delayed and promised to try again in January. Sec. Hargett, one of the law’s opponents, recently sent the TBI to investigate fair election proponent Bernie Ellis for what he claimed was a “terrorist threat.” The TBI confirmed the Sec.’s claim was “unsubstantiated.” [...]

  10. Nony Mouse says:

    While I wish Mr Ellis (and the votors of TN) well in the quest to get human-verifiable ballots enshrined in law and implemented in fact, I think someone needs to respond to the Newscoma comment.
    The reason that one does not (and in my mind) should not receive any sort of receipt to carry away from the voting place is a matter of intimidation. Imagine if your place of employment (or union or biggest customer or unemployment/pension office) was under the thrall of a person of substantial political partisianship. The threat against your livlihood if you didn’t vote their way is meaningless right now, because no one can PROVE anything. “You won’t see a dime from here ever again if you don’t show me your vote receipt says X” would be possible with receipts. And what if, say, a union official demanded you vote one way and a manager demanded you vote the other? Contentious in-laws of opposite political views? No, thanks.